Building on our earlier conversation about Golden Globes, I reached out to many different female film writers and bloggers about the Oscar nominations.
I laid out a couple of things to consider:
- A woman directed movie, The Hurt Locker matched a male directed movie, Avatar – nomination for nomination. Pretty groundbreaking.
- 3 of the 10 best picture nominations — Precious, An Education, The Blind Side — were for movies about women.
- 2 of the 10 best picture nominations were directed by women — An Education, The Hurt Locker.
- Only one of the five nominees for best adapted screenplay has a woman: District 9 – Written by Neill Blomkamp and Terri Tatchell
- NO woman was nominated for original screenplay.
- Bright Star got only one nomination for costume design.
- Meryl Streep got her 16th nomination, the most ever and Sandra Bullock as well as Gabby Sidibe and Carey Mulligan got their firsts.
- Lastly, what does Bigelow’s nomination here and win at the DGA mean for women directors (if anything.)
The participants include (in alphabetical order):
Manohla Dargis, NY Times: Jan Lisa Huttner, The Hot Pink Pen; MaryAnn Johanson, Flick Filosopher; Jenni Miller, Cinematical; Mary Pols, Time; Katey Rich, Cinemablend; Carrie Rickey, Philadelphia Inquirer; Shannon Ridler, The Movie Moxie; Sasha Stone, Awards Daily; Ella Taylor, LA Weekly
Some answered the questions, some gave other quotes and thoughts.
Manohla Dargis:
I’m just glad that Bigelow has received this initial recognition. There’s really not much more that can be said on this subject until she actually wins.
Jan Lisa Huttner:
Although the number of noms is the same the quality of these noms is very different. With the exception of Best Picture & Best Director, AVATAR’s noms are all technical, whereas noms for THE HURT LOCKER include the major categories of BEST ACTOR & BEST ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY. (Major/Minor being determined by what gets announced on Nominations Morning versus what just goes out in the press release for Oscar junkies like us.) In this respect, ROTTEN TOMATOES is an accurate guide. As of today, AVATAR stands @ 82% Fresh whereas THE HURT LOCKER stands @ 97% Fresh, way ahead of all other candidates qualitatively speaking.
I’m especially pleased that Jeremy Renner was nominated because his face in close-up is the core image in THE HURT LOCKER & I think Kathryn Bigelow directed him brilliantly. I have some hope that the 9 noms will make more people see his extraordinary performance now that THE HURT LOCKER is a top contender beyond the best director barrier-buster. Momentum for THE HURT LOCKER will surely build as more people see it, & if a significant number of voters decide to “vote the ticket,” he just might squeak thru. One lives in hope!
This is a break-through year for women characters, & in particular, this should be appreciated as “the year of the woman as teacher.” Look at the all the contenders again & you’ll see this thread running through almost all of this year’s “female-oriented” noms. Who saves Precious? Ms. Rain! Who saves Jenny? Miss Stubbs! (See more on this below.) Who are Leigh Anne Tuohy’s key allies: Miss Sue (Kathy Bates) & Mrs. Boswell (Kim Dickens).
If I ruled the world, contenders would have included BRIGHT STAR, JULIE & JULIA, and THE LOVELY BONES. Me, I nominated UP IN THE AIR for the Women Film Critics Circle’s “Hall of Shame Award,” & to call it “an adaptation” of Walter Kirns’ book is ludicrous.
I have BRIGHT STAR as a Top Contender in my own BEST ADAPTED SCREENPLAY category. Whether you agree with me on this or not, I sincerely believe that BRIGHT STAR stands in much closer relation to Andrew Motion’s KEATS Bio than the “adaptation” of Walter Kirns’ novel in the UP IN THE AIR screenplay. But bottom line, in this particular category I am simply thrilled that Nick Hornby was nominated for AN EDUCATION!!! His screenplay opens with Miss Stubbs, closes with Miss Stubbs, & has Miss Stubbs mention the name “Mr. Rochester” THREE TIMES in between, so shame on anyone who’s surprised to learn that David “has secrets” in Act Three!!!
But here’s a fact that’s more important: Meryl Streep has not won an Oscar in 26 years!!! Yet again, critics have used her brilliance primarily to damn her collaborators (in this case Amy Adams & Nora Ephron)–what’s up with that?!? If they’re going to reward Jeff Bridges for CRAZY HEART then for sure, they should NOT “yawn” about Streep this year & pass her over yet again. (And I say this also having loved all the other contenders).
The Bigelow nomination means EVERYTHING!!! Another huge crack in the celluloid ceiling!!! Do not buy into the BS: Bigelow’s films have often included strong supporting women’s roles not to mention two wonderful female leads (Jamie Leigh Curtis in BLUE STEEL & Sara Polley in THE WEIGHT OF WATER). Most offensive: Embedding in the gossipy “Exes Issue” is the not so subtle implication that she’s riding on Cameron’s coat tails. Those of us who know better must fight back!!! Yes, she’s a babe. Yes, she’s got great legs. Yes, she was once married to James Cameron. But, guess what: THE HURT LOCKER is a riveting film that’s 97% Fresh, Bigelow has Lifetime Achievement, & oh yes, women hold up half the sky! Continue reading ‘Women Writers React to the Oscar Nominations’
Tags:
Academy Awards,
Bright Star,
Kathryn Bigelow,
Meryl Streep,
The Hurt Locker
Recent Comments